Natural Diamonds
Natural diamonds formed deep in the earth over a billion years or more and were carried up by volcanic eruptions. They look the same as lab-grown diamonds, so what you pay for is rarity, origin and a better chance of holding some value.
On this page
- How natural diamonds form
- What makes a natural diamond rare
- Natural vs lab-grown diamonds
- Do natural diamonds hold their value?
- Natural diamonds and ethics
- How to buy a natural diamond well
- How natural diamonds are identified and graded
- Designing a natural diamond ring in Ring Studio
- Natural fancy colour and vintage diamonds
- Formed
- About 150 to 200 km deep, commonly 1 to 3 billion years ago
- Brought up by
- Deep-source volcanic pipes (kimberlite, lamproite)
- Hardness
- 10 on the Mohs scale
- Main appeal
- Rarity, origin story, relative value retention
- Main drawback
- Several times the price of an equivalent lab diamond
How natural diamonds form
Natural diamonds grew in the earth's mantle, where temperatures are over a thousand degrees Celsius and pressure is tens of thousands of times greater than at the surface. Under those conditions carbon atoms bond into diamond's tight cubic lattice. Most gem diamonds formed between roughly one and three billion years ago.
They reached the surface much later through rare, fast, deep-source eruptions that punched pipes of kimberlite or lamproite through the crust. Some diamonds stayed in those pipes; others were eroded out and carried by rivers into alluvial and marine deposits. Major producing countries include Russia, Botswana, Canada, Australia, South Africa, Angola, Namibia and the Democratic Republic of the Congo.
What makes a natural diamond rare
Diamond is not rare as a material, but large, clean, well-coloured crystals are. Many tonnes of ore are processed for each carat recovered, and most diamonds recovered are not gem quality. Of those that are, cutting typically removes half or more of the rough weight to reveal a well-proportioned stone. That is why natural diamond prices climb steeply with size: a 2 carat diamond is far more than twice the price of a 1 carat of the same quality. See diamond price per carat for how this works.
Natural vs lab-grown diamonds
| Natural | Lab-grown | |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Diamond (carbon) | Diamond (carbon) |
| Hardness, sparkle | Identical | Identical |
| Age | Billions of years | Weeks |
| Price | High | A fraction, and falling |
| Resale | Moderate, below retail | Low |
| Identification | Lab report | Lab report; usually inscribed |
The deeper comparison is in lab-grown diamond vs natural diamond.
Do natural diamonds hold their value?
Better than lab-grown, not as well as most people hope. The gap between retail price and what a dealer will pay second-hand is wide, and natural diamond prices have softened in recent years as lab-grown stones have taken a large share of the engagement ring market. Natural diamonds still keep meaningful resale value, particularly well-graded stones above a carat, and they have a heritage appeal for heirloom rings. Treat a natural diamond as a lasting possession, not an investment, and this is not financial advice.
Natural diamonds and ethics
The Kimberley Process Certification Scheme, set up in 2003, tracks rough diamond shipments between member countries to stop "conflict diamonds" funding rebel groups. It is a real safeguard but a limited one: it does not cover broader human rights or environmental issues, and it tracks shipments rather than individual stones. Many retailers now offer diamonds with stated country of origin or mine-to-market traceability. Our page on ethical and conflict-free diamonds goes into this.
Mining also supports major economies. In Botswana, for example, diamonds are a cornerstone of public finances. The ethics of buying natural or lab-grown are genuinely nuanced.
How to buy a natural diamond well
- Buy on cut first. Cut quality drives sparkle more than any other C. See diamond cut grades.
- Choose an eye-clean clarity, not a perfect one. VS2 and many SI1 stones look clean to the eye; see the diamond clarity chart.
- Match colour to metal. G to H in platinum or white gold; I to J can look great in yellow gold.
- Buy just under a magic weight. A 0.9 ct stone can cost noticeably less than a 1.0 ct and look almost identical.
- Insist on an independent report. GIA is the benchmark for natural diamonds; see diamond certificates.
Like character over perfection? Salt and pepper diamonds are natural diamonds with visible inclusions, at much lower prices than clean stones of the same size.
How natural diamonds are identified and graded
Because a natural diamond and a lab-grown diamond look the same, identification is done by gem labs rather than by eye. Labs use spectroscopy, ultraviolet imaging and fluorescence patterns to confirm that a diamond grew in the earth and has not been treated. Natural stones show growth features and trace-element signatures that differ from those of HPHT and CVD diamonds.
Once origin is confirmed, the stone is graded on the 4Cs. For a natural centre stone of meaningful size, an independent report is essential: it records the measurements, proportions and a plot of inclusions, and many labs laser-inscribe a report number on the girdle so the stone can be matched to its paperwork. The diamond colour chart and clarity chart explain what the grades mean. If you are inheriting a stone without paperwork, a jeweller can send it for grading before you reset it.
Designing a natural diamond ring in Ring Studio
Ring Studio lets you choose natural or lab-grown diamond for your centre stone. Because the two look identical, the difference you will see in the app is in the live price estimate, which is a useful way to feel the trade-off before talking to a jeweller.
- Choose your shape, carat and setting, then set the stone to natural diamond.
- Drop the carat slightly, for example from 1.0 to 0.9, and see how little the stone's look changes on the hand.
- Compare the estimate with the same ring in lab-grown.
- Add side stones or a halo; small natural diamonds add less to the cost than you might expect.
- Share the ring code with your jeweller and ask them to source a graded natural diamond to match.
Natural fancy colour and vintage diamonds
Most natural diamonds are near-colourless, but some are yellow, brown, pink, blue or black. Yellow is the most available of the fancy colours; see yellow diamond engagement rings. Vintage stones such as old mine cuts are also natural diamonds, often cut by hand over a century ago, and reusing one is about as sustainable as diamond buying gets.
Frequently asked questions
How old are natural diamonds?
Most gem diamonds are thought to be between about one and three billion years old. They formed roughly 150 to 200 kilometres below the surface and were brought up much later by deep volcanic eruptions in kimberlite and lamproite pipes.
Can you tell a natural diamond from a lab-grown one by eye?
No. Even an experienced jeweller cannot reliably tell them apart with a loupe. Gem labs use spectroscopy and imaging instruments to identify origin, which is why a grading report matters.
Do natural diamonds hold their value?
Better than lab-grown diamonds, but they are not a reliable investment. You will usually sell a natural diamond for well below its retail price. Larger, rarer stones with strong grading tend to hold value best.
Are natural diamonds conflict-free?
The Kimberley Process aims to keep rough diamonds from funding rebel wars, but critics say its definition is narrow. Ask your jeweller for origin information or traceability where available.
Why are natural diamonds so expensive?
Gem-quality rough is rare, mining is costly, and only part of each rough crystal survives cutting. Prices also reflect quality: an extra colour or clarity grade, or a jump past a carat threshold, can change the price significantly.